Extraction form for project: Interventions for intermittent exotropia (2013)

Arm Details

1. number of eyes/participants randomized in this study:
Bilateral lateral rectus recession:
Multiple Choice
Participants...
Eyes...
Check here if not reported/can’t tell...
2. number of eyes/participants lost follow-up in this study:
Bilateral lateral rectus recession:
Multiple Choice
Participants...
Eyes...
Check here if not reported/can’t tell...
3. number of eyes/participants analyzed in this study:
Bilateral lateral rectus recession:
Multiple Choice
Participants...
Eyes...
Check here if not reported/can’t tell...
4. Description of interventions:
Type "None" if no additional description
Bilateral lateral rectus recession:

Design

1. Page
2. Methods
3. Children diagnosed with basic X(T)
4. Interventions
5. At a minimum of 1 year post surgery (12 to 15 months)
6. Satisfactory
7. Unsatisfactory
8. Notes
9. Random sequence generation (selection bias):Authors' judgement
10. Random sequence generation (selection bias):Support for judgement
11. Allocation concealment (selection bias):Authors' judgement
12. Allocation concealment (selection bias):Support for judgement
13. Blinding (performance bias and detection bias):Authors' judgement
14. Blinding (performance bias and detection bias):Support for judgement
15. Incomplete outcome data (attrition bias):Authors' judgement
16. Incomplete outcome data (attrition bias):Support for judgement
17. Selective reporting (reporting bias):Authors' judgement
18. Selective reporting (reporting bias):Support for judgement
19. Other bias:Authors' judgement
20. Other bias:Support for judgement

Baselines

N/A

Outcome Details

1. Were data available?
Example of selecting "No": (1) precision measures were not reported anywhere in the text or graphs; (2) reported only statistical significance without providing the exact P value.
Motor alignment:
Single Choice
Yes, precision measures are numeric and can be extracted for meta-analysis
Yes, but precision measures cannot be extracted accurately (e.g., presented in a difficult-to-read graph)
No
Can't tell
2. Time points for which data were reported:
Only specify other time points if >12 months
Motor alignment:
Baseline
Single Choice
Yes
No
Can't tell
One or more time points after baseline and ≤12 months
Single Choice
Yes
No
Can't tell
Other (please specify):
3. Any other relevant information about how data were collected or reported?
Type "None" if no additional comments
Motor alignment:

Quality

1. Adjust Quality Rating (for Key Questions: 1)
Quality Guideline Used:
Select Current Overall Rating:
Single Choice
Notes on this Rating:

Suggested Arms

NameDescription
Bilateral lateral rectus recession
Unilateral lateral rectus recessionunilateral lateral rectus recession with medial rectus resection.

Please see downloadable data for more

Suggested Outcomes

TypeDomainSpecific Measurement
CategoricalMotor alignmentMotor alignment at near and distance fixation using the simultaneous or alternate prism cover test, or both, or using the synoptophore
CategoricalMotor fusion testMotor fusion test at near or distance, or both
ContinuousStereoacuityStereoacuity at near using any age-appropriate test
ContinuousStereoacuity at distance

Please see downloadable data for more